Book Reviews China Land of Dragons and Emperors |
Reviews from Teachers |
Beginning with the first emperor, Quin Shi-huang, ascending the throne in 247 BC ready to amalgamate the seven states, the reader is given an overview of just how he maintained power, deciding to build the Great Wall, and using 700,000 men from all over China to build his tomb. His tyrannical rule saw canals, highways and bridges built, and he stipulated that every book before his rule be burned and that history should begin with him. Within this chapter is also a double page spread about the Terracotta Army and a scattering of astounding facts about the tomb. Each of the 10 chapters goes on in this vein, giving a potted history, an amazement of facts and inserts which reveal more information about specific subjects. In chapter three concerning the Han dynasty, we read of the Silk Road, in chapter five, within the Tang dynasty appears a double page spreads about Printing. Each chapter has a specialist section within its pages, expanding on something for which China is famous. For the specialist or for the interested reader, for the student, class and teacher, this book is a winner. Its profusion of photos, drawings, maps, and inserts makes it an entertaining and informative book to read. In a class room, a set of this book will be a most useful addition for students of China, history or the Olympics. It gives a tantalizing insight into the country where this year’s Olympic Games is to be held; a country which is gaining in prestige and influence in world politics and a country to which Australia is increasingly tied. Highly recommended. Judith Way , Mill Park Secondary College, VIC
China: Land of Dragons and Emperors is a perfect starting point for any young person exploring China’s country and its culture.
Jodie Webber, Hurlstone Agriculture High School, NSW China: Land of Dragons and Emperors is a wonderful book by a favourite author. This time, Adeline Yen Mah has brought us a non-fiction book just in time for the Beijing Olympics. The beautiful design of the book brings history to life and the small chunks of information made the book very readable, whether it is cover to cover or dipping in and out of pages that grab you. An excellent index also contributes to the overall appeal of the book. China: Land of Dragons and Emperors could be used by classes in a few different ways:
Knowing that many students will be studying China this year (and into the future), China: Land of Dragons and Emperors is a book that every school library should have at least one copy of. Julie Davies, Sutherland Shire Christian School, NSW There are generously sprinkled black and white illustrations: line drawings, diagrams and photographs, a bibliography (including websites), comprehensive index and a very handy timeline. While there are included two 2-page maps, I found it frustrating that there were often references to cities which I couldn’t find on either map. Another helpful addition would be a pronunciation guide for the most common Chinese diphthongs. Sometimes these are given in the text, but not always, and a systematic list would be very useful. This is a good introduction to an important and very significant part of Chinese history. It is, however, somewhat repetitive (see for example the discussion of gunpowder, Pages 147 and 188) and sometimes it is a little less than clear to which earlier referent the author is alluding. In the introductory To the Reader section, the author provides a simple but compelling reason for all libraries to hold one copy at least of this book: Presently, one-fifth of the world’s population is Chinese, totaling over1300 million people. There are more Chinese learning English today than all the native English speakers on Earth. One day China could become the number one English-speaking nation as well as the world’s largest manufacturer and consumer. Perhaps it is time to know something about China. (p.xi) For teachers wanting teaching materials for backgrounding a unit on the forthcoming Olympics, we will need to look elsewhere. For those teaching a unit on Ancient China, as our Year 7 HSIE staff is doing this term, China: Land of Dragons and Emperors will be an invaluable resource. Susan Stephenson, NSW China : Land of Dragons and Emperors , though packed with fascinating facts, does not have the off-putting appearance of densely written text. It is well set-out, with plenty of white space, and interspersed with text boxes, maps, black and white illustrations, and photographs. There are so many places where Yen Mah shows her skill in targeting young readers. Like the section on the Chinese language, where she tells kids exactly what not to say to a Chinese person in Mandarin (Good one, Adeline!) China : Land of Dragons and Emperors would make a great addition to a Stage 3 classroom, or the school library. It can be read in a linear way, first looking at myth, then moving through recorded history, or dipped into via the contents and index as a reference book. With heightened interest in China because of the 08 Olympics, it gives students from Year 5/6 and beyond the opportunity to delve into a truly fascinating and ancient culture. Isabelle Baelde, Marcellin College Randwick, NSW The information and illustrations provided are enough to allow entertaining light reading, kids just do not have time to get bored, the story goes on with the next tyrant. By small touches, one invention after another, the author gives tribute to China’s contribution to the world history and progress, but she does not turn a blind eye to its darker times. Like most countries with a long history, China has quite a few skeletons in its closet. Adeline will sometimes warn the reader of some dreadful things coming up. The Great Wall of China compared to a cemetery is an indication that the author has not shied away from sad but true facts. This history of China will attract young readers because it is full of fascinating stories and characters and gives a human dimension to this gigantic and so little known country. It can be used in class but also read on its own, its compact size and mix of historical facts, anecdotes and curiosities makes it a very attractive book. Helen Wilde, SA The presentation of the text is very attractive, with some handwritten style fonts, and lots of illustrations, including drawings, photographs and maps. The book is in black, white and grey, so some of the richness of the visual feast are lost, but the text is enhanced by these visuals. The font size is reader friendly, and the text is broken into short, manageable pieces, with the language and layout making the book suitable for an age group ranging through 10-15. Adults interested in a quick read of Chinese history and culture would also find it interesting and useful. The addition of a Timeline and an index would help with middle school study. The short section on language is fascinating, and Yen Mah's chatty tone extends to providing a list of words to avoid in Mandarin, which would no doubt be of great interest to some young readers! I am able to report that as somewhat of a˜Sha gua” myself, I still found this a highly accessible and fascinating read, one which I will enjoy going back to for some time to come. Shelly Draga, Auckland, New Zealand It begins with the Chinese dragon, a mythical creature which is connected with water and rainfall. In times of drought, government ministers offered sacrifices to the dragon and prayed for rain. The book goes on to explain lucky and unlucky numbers as well as what colours mean in China. For example; Red is the colour of fire, it corresponds to summer and the south and also symbolizes success, happiness and good luck. We read that the history of China goes back thousands of years but the book starts 2200 years ago with the First Emperor, who united China. We go on to read why the Great Wall of China was built and how a tomb for the Emperor was constructed, where thousands of terracotta life-size soldiers and horses were made to protect the tomb. The book continues through history with the founding of other dynasties; The Han, The Tang, The Song until the last crippled dynasty; The Qing in 1912. The history of China in the twentieth century is remarkably different, with China being dominated by four men. We learn about Communism in China and why and how Taiwan became a democratic society in 1988. Scattered through out the book are interesting facts; for example - what are eunuchs? Who is Confucius? What is the Silk Road? What happens during Chinese New Year? What is the Moon Festival? There are also interesting revelations of inventions; cast iron, paper, matches and fireworks and many more. After being completely absorbed by this book, I would thoroughly recommend China: Land of Dragons and Emperors to young and old alike. It would be an excellent read for 10 year olds plus and be a valuable tool in the classroom, especially with The Olympic Games being held in China in a few months. Many classes will be studying China and The Olympic Games and this book will fill in many gaps of the knowledge of China. There are black and white maps and pictures throughout out the book and also a valuable timeline of China’s rich history at the back. China: Land of Dragons and Emperors is a fascinating book and I highly recommend it. Barbara Wilson, St George Christian School, Hurstville NSW Interspersed throughout are relevant sections on subjects like education, the Great Wall, Terracotta Army, Inventions, Women, Chinese New Year and Confucius, The history is accurate and well organized, with enough detail to provide a coherent account, but not so overburdened with content to deter the average reader non-historian. The language level would suit students from age twelve and up and the print size and style is clear and appropriate. At the end of the book there is a timeline, useful references and an index. The obvious application for using this volume, published in China's Olympic year, might seem to be in a unit on the Olympics. Primary students would probably find the monochromatic publication less appealing than other full-colour volumes, but older students wanting solid, carefully researched and written information will be delighted by this book. Rachel Froude, Galen College, Wangaratta, VIC The text is supported by explanations of unusual words to give the reader a thorough understanding of what they are reading, words such as eunuch. Other helpful and interesting additions are the pronunciation of Chinese words, especially names which generally would be impossible for the reader to know. Illustrations, shading and boxes also assist the readers’ enjoyment of the book. The pockets of information are easy to cope with and encourage the reader to keep turning the pages. However, I was disappointed that the illustrations are all in black and white. Colour would have further enhanced the reader’s visual pleasure of the book. The fact that only emperors wore yellow would have not only been visually informative but also pleasant to the eye. Also the gorgeous silks, Ming vases and other Chinese wonders would have been a delight in colour. Students of any age will enjoy this compact and readable account of China ’s history, especially from the trusted pen of Adeline Yen Mah. |